Comments on: Melody Thornton Dissing Nicole Scherzinger

By: Cat

Cat — Fri, 24 Jul 2009 05:49:19 +0000

Hi there, I think melody has a stronger voice than Nicole. She’s younger, has more energy and has star quality as well. However I think Nicole is more polished as an entertainer and exudes “pussycat dolls” aura. Melody can sing but Pussycat dolls is NOT an R and B group and it seems with the concerts that I have seen that Melody brings her R and B roots to the group which doesn’t mix because pussycat dolls is more cabaret/jazzy kind of feel. I think Melody is

1) Too R&B (which is not bad but I think her style takes away the magic of PCD)

2) Too loud (She reminds me of spice girl–like “girl power” PCD is more mature and sultry..maybe it comes with Melody’s age I don’t know but she seems like she’s angry almost)

3) Too girly (PCD reminds me of Victoria’s secret..anyone who’s seen Melody would probably agree with me..she’s too “girly power” “oh no you did aint” kinda thing going.

My advise to Melody: Girl you are talented and a fire cracker I say instead of Nicole Launching a career you are a better fit to go on your own..cause your voice is strong and you are a bundle of energy. If I was your PR I’d market you along the lines of Beyonce, Britney etc..etc but NOT as a Pussycat dolls.

My advise to Nicole: Keep your composure and always stay professional. People will try to push buttons but you already made a mark as a PCD doll lead singer. There will be people saying its unfair blah blah..but remember even destiny’s child has beyonce as the lead..what’s wrong with that?? However I don’t think this is the right time to go solo yet..the fans are too happy for you to keep singing for PCD. You exude PCD..and as such you are a success regardless because you have brought this group to where they are now..and that’s something that can’t be taken away girl. Keep it up!

By: sophie

sophie — Mon, 15 Jun 2009 15:40:26 +0000

I think i would be annoyed if Nicole ALWAYS gets the big roles. They DID sing solo songs on the new album but that was on the delux edition. So fans had to pay extra, just to hear the other girls sing more than very quiet background vocals.
Nicole is good at singing, but so are the others. Because if you look at some of their old burlesque shows before they were recording artists, they are all really good singers.
Also, if what i have heard is true. About Nicole wanting to change the name to The Pussycat Dolls ft Nicole Sherzinger. I think that is out of order. Because, even though Nicole steals most of the lime light, they are still a group. She doesnt need to steal any more.
& It seems that it is getting worse. In their first album you could sort of hear the others. & Now, in their newest single. Hush Hush, you can ONLY hear Nicole’s vocals. & Most of the camera time is on Nicole aswell.
I really dont want to see PCD split, because i love them. But, they really do need more equalised amounts of singing time.

By: AmyGrindhouse

AmyGrindhouse — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 06:26:09 +0000

Welcome and thanks for the comment Berry. Melody is often mocked for being shrill and nasal. I think it’s the fans who are not wanting this to work and so it sucks for her.

By: berry

berry — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 05:51:23 +0000

I think that melody has a good voice, but during concerts, she does end up sounding a little weird & not as good as nicole.

I heard the solo tracks on Doll Domination and i only actually liked Space .. the others, i just didnt really like.

I think if there’s a problem, Melody & nicole, or the whole group should just talk about it, vent or do something that’ll prevent them from ending the same way as DK .

because they are the best right now .. and it would suck to have them split because i really think they’re no good solo and are way better staying as a group together..

By: AmyGrindhouse

AmyGrindhouse — Tue, 28 Apr 2009 22:11:26 +0000

nadine love doctor – welcome to the site and thank you for the comment – they did not sign up for that, and that is a fair assertion. They know the score by now though and should have left already if it bothered them, don’t you think?

By: AmyGrindhouse

AmyGrindhouse — Tue, 28 Apr 2009 22:07:11 +0000

Hey roro – welcome to the site and thank you for leaving the comment.

Thank you for calling out Melody’s lack of action. She could be perusing a million other things… Carmit left. Why did she not leave too?

By: roro

roro — Tue, 28 Apr 2009 22:00:49 +0000

Very childish Melody, that’s why Robin didn’t make you a lead pussycat! Go on your solo if your so miserable there- your staying with PCD because of what???? Leave then, like right NOW—Follow your dreams. all talk but no action Melody.

By: nadine love doctor

nadine love doctor — Tue, 28 Apr 2009 11:14:23 +0000

i agree with melody i dont think the rest of the dolls signed up to be in the back ground all there career. Melody is very talented and should be able to show that without just doing oooooooooo’s and aaaahhhhhhh’s all the time

By: AmyGrindhouse

AmyGrindhouse — Tue, 28 Apr 2009 06:29:09 +0000

Teehee, I think Melody needs a reality check… and, no

By: Mystery Man

Mystery Man — Tue, 28 Apr 2009 04:00:35 +0000

um…who is this cvhick again? when she can actually step up to Nicole’s talent…or win a reality show in the mid 90s like she did, then she can talk. Othersie she should just sit back there like nice little kitty and wait for th edya when Nicole leaves. We all know it’s coming.

btw…is that keri hilson chik the #2 doll?

By: AmyGrindhouse

AmyGrindhouse — Mon, 27 Apr 2009 22:36:43 +0000

Oh, you so have a point.

Whatever rows are going on, this is not a good sign. They are Danity Kane version 2.0.

You are also right that the rest of the troupe do not seem to mind being scantily-clad set decoration. There’s a recession damn it, she should be grateful she has a pay cheque at all.

By: AmyGrindhouse

AmyGrindhouse — Mon, 27 Apr 2009 22:21:18 +0000

Melody has been called shrill by more than one critic reviewing their show – you have a point and she should not look a gift horse in the mouth.

By: Bleakey

Bleakey — Mon, 27 Apr 2009 22:17:19 +0000

Well go head Melody lol. I remember in an interview she said she wanted to be the next Mariah Carey. Um……yeah. The other girls don’t seem to mind being background singers/performers but obviously she does. I actually really liked The Pussycat Dolls when they were a burlesque troupe that performed old songs. Now it seems they are going to end up another Danity Kane.

By: Firecracker

Firecracker — Mon, 27 Apr 2009 21:56:50 +0000

Melody Tranny (don’t care about her last name), please! Nicole is the reason why the Pussycat Dolls are famous. She needs to STFU.